Home       Dictionary Last Lecture Lecture List Next Lecture

 

 

 

 

There have been several mass extinctions over evolutionary time; the best known is the one that occurred at the Cretaceous-Tertiary border or K/T boundary. A mass extinction is defined as one that affected a wide range of animals and plants on a world-wide scale.

Home       Dictionary Last Lecture Lecture List Next Lecture

 

The five major extinctions were:

bullet

Mid-Permian - 58 % of families were lost

bullet

Permian-Triassic boundary - 49 % of families lost

bullet

End of the Triassic - 22 % of families lost

bullet

Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary - 14 % of families lost

bullet

Eocene-Oligocene - 8 % of families lost

It is not known whether these extinctions were world wide but it is certainly involved a broad range of species.

The extinction rate > new species evolving

It is important to remember that the disappearance of species does not always mean extinction, sometimes it can be due to evolution. For example:

 

bullet

Therapsida         ----------->    Mammalia

bullet

Theropoda         ----------->    Aves                 ------------> Evolution

bullet

Pliohippus         ----------->    Equus

 

bullet

Sauropoda            ------------>

bullet

Pterosauria          ------------>                       ------------> Extinction

bullet

Multituberculata    ------------>

 

 

The Late Cretaceous extinction is well known as the 'one that killed off the dinosaurs.' At the time of the extinction dinosaurs had dominated terrestrial environments for perhaps 150 million years, so why and how did they die out?

 

There are several hypotheses, with evidence to support all of them, hence there is very interesting controversy.

 

bullet

Hypothesis 1 - The dinosaurs were wiped out due to a  cosmic disaster

This suggests that as an asteroid or comet hit the earth; there were fire storms or it blocked out the sun, preventing photosynthesis, leading to the extinction of animals. The effect of an impact would last only days, or weeks, at the most years.

 

bullet

Hypothesis 2: The dinosaur population was already declining          

This more favoured hypothesis suggests that the transition was very gradual, starting millions of years before the end of the Cretaceous.  Slow climatic or geographical changes as a result of continental drift and temperature changes were factors. These climatic changes would have an effect over thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, of years.

 

 

bullet

        Evidence

It is difficult to determine the abruptness of the extinctions. Dinosaur fossils are very rare so it is difficult to tell from the fossil record when the population was declining. Only in Wyoming in North America are there continuous terrestrial deposits through the K/T boundary. Casper in Wyoming, lies in the middle of this area. Geologists estimate that the monthly temperatures varied between 11°C and 34°C, whereas they now vary between -27°C and +40°C. This indicates that the once subtropical area (suitable for dinosaurs) presently experiences continental weather, with cold winters and hot summers (not suitable for large animals that could not hibernate).

This evidence also shows that sea levels were falling by 150-200m. As it is thought that Late Cretaceous dinosaurs dominated the rivers and flood plains, the available habitats would have declined.

However, most palaeontologists agree that an impact of some kind did hit the earth during the Late Cretaceous, because a narrow band of rock with high concentrations of iridium is present in many parts of the world, in both marine and terrestrial sediments known to have been deposited during this time. A large crater in Mexico, called Chicxulub is believed to be the site of the impact. Chixculub has been measured as 176 km (110 miles) across! 

 

 

So why did some animals survive when the dinosaurs didnt?

All modern tetrapod groups including mammals arose in the late Triassic - late Jurassic and increased in diversity throughout this time.

During the Cretaceous, the diversity of mammals and other tetrapod groups equalled that of the dinosaurs. By the late Cretaceous, mammals were twice as diverse as dinosaurs, this was before the K/T extinction, as shown by the diagram below. The figures are from Bug Creek, a famous fossil site near a major water way.

 

 

 

Most non-avian dinosaurs became extinct but turtles, crocodiles and most mammals survived. It appears that aquatic species were not as badly affected as terrestrial ones. Floral extinctions were also much less dramatic than faunal extinctions. In general, Archibald (1996) shows that:

Ectotherms    ------>                                 Endotherms

Freshwater    ------>    were more             Terrestrial

Small            ------>    likely to survive       Large

Non-amniotes ------>     than......               Amniotes

Placentals ------>                                      Marsupials 

 

There were 19 families of known reptiles in the Late Cretaceous:

4 only occurred at single sites

8 only survived up to the K/T boundary (e.g. Triceratops and Tyrannosaurus rex)

7 died out before the K/T boundary was reached

 

How where other groups affected?

5/6 placental genera survived through the K/T boundary

4/8 multituberculate  genera survived through the K/T boundary

1/5 marsupial genera survived through the K/T boundary

 

We can not draw firm conclusions but the general consensus is that a catastrophe was not responsible for the extinction of the dinosaurs. Their numbers were already declining and had been for a long period of time. However, a natural disaster did occur at the end of the Cretaceous and is likely to have contributed significantly to the final extinction of dinosaurs. Other groups of animals were also affected.

 

Further Reading:

Archibald, J.P. (1996) Dinosaur Extinction & The end of an era. Columbia University Press, New York.

Fatovsky, D.E. & Weishampel, D.B. (1996) The Evolution and Extinction of the Dinosaurs. Cambridge University Press, USA. 460pp

Pough, F.H., Janis, C.M. & Heiser J.B. (2002) Vertebrate Life.  Chapter 14: pages 403 – 404